9. Della Chatfield & Elmer Ellsworth Chatfield

by Catherine Sevenau on April 24, 2011

FAMILY LINE AND HISTORY

Della “Dell” Chatfield

  • 1st of 9 children of Clark Samuel Chatfield & Mary Elizabeth Morrow
  • Born: Jan 4, 1872, Tecumseh, Johnson County, Nebraska
  • Died: Oct 31, 1919 (age 47), Worland, Washakie County, Wyoming; cancer
  • Buried: Riverview Cemetery in Worland, Washakie County, Wyoming
  • Occupation: Singer, contralto with the Chicago Opera Company
  • Married: Sep 18, 1892, Elmer Ellsworth Chatfield (1st cousin), Ogden, Weber County, Utah
  • Five daughters: Helen Layle Chatfield, Marion Hortense Chatfield, Sevilla Maude “Shirley” Chatfield, Audrey Ella Chatfield, Constance Cordelia “Babe” Chatfield

Elmer Ellsworth “Chatty” Chatfield

  • 3rd of 9 children of Isaac Willard Chatfield & Eliza Ann Harrington
  • Born: Jun 12, 1863, Florence, Fremont County, Colorado
  • Died: Sep 20, 1962 (age 99), Thermopolis, Hot Springs County, Wyoming; head shingles
  • Buried: Sep 24, 1962, Riverview Cemetery in Worland, Washakie County, Wyoming
  • Occupation: Cattle/sheep rancher, horse dealer, farmer
  • Affiliations: Carbondale Gun Club (Aspen 1891)
  • Married: Sep 18, 1892, Della Chatfield (1st cousin), Ogden, Weber County, Utah
  • Five daughters: Helen Layle Chatfield, Marion Hortense Chatfield, Sevilla Maude “Shirley” Chatfield, Audrey Ella Chatfield, Constance Cordelia “Babe” Chatfield

1. Helen Layle Chatfield

  • Born: Feb 15, 1894, Emma, Pitkin County, Colorado
  • Died: Dec 26, 1975 (age 81), Refugio County, Texas
  • Buried: Oakwood Cemetery in Refugio, Refugio County, Texas
  • Married: abt 1926, Rudolph Oscar “Rudy” Hornburg (a widower)
  • One stepdaughter from Rudy: Ruth Geraldine Hornburg
  • Two children: Walter Jerald Hornburg, Marian Norma Hornburg

2. Marion Hortense Chatfield

  • Born: Feb 25, 1896, Spring Creek, Big Horn County, Wyoming
  • Died: Jun 18, 1980 (age 84), Angwin, Napa County, California; cancer
  • Buried: St. Helena Public Cemetery in St. Helena, Napa County, California
  • Married: 1934, William Perry Tarter, Rock Springs, Sweetwater County, Wyoming
  • Three children: Helen Marie Tarter, Margaret Eloise Tarter, Clark Delmer Tarter

3. Sevilla Maude “Shirley” Chatfield

  • Born: Oct 18, 1898, Spring Creek, Big Horn County, Wyoming
  • Died: Mar 30, 1981 (age 82), San Marcos, San Diego County, California; heart attack
  • Buried: Eternal Hills Cemetery in Oceanside, San Diego County, California
  • Married: Apr 10, 1920, Frederick Chester Sproul, Manderson, Big Horn Co., Wyoming
  • Three Children: Elmer Chatfield Sproul, Frederick Chester Sproul, Jr., Beverly Ann Sproul

4. Audrey Ella Chatfield

  • Born: Nov 27, 1900, Spring Creek, Big Horn County, Wyoming
  • Died: Jan 31, 2000 (age 99), near Jackson, Teton County, Wyoming; stroke
  • Cremated: Remains in Riverview Cemetery in Worland, Washakie County, Wyoming
  • Married: Feb 26, 1927, Joseph Anthony “Joe” Bodan, Brownsville, Cameron County, Texas
  • Three children: Barbara Lee Bodan, Emerson Ellsworth Bodan, Nancy Dolores Bodan

5. Constance Cordelia “Babe” “Connie” Chatfield

  • Born: Dec 18, 1905, Basin, Big Horn County, Wyoming
  • Died: May 26, 1990 (age 84), Fairfield, Solano County, California; complications from diabetes
  • Buried: Suisan-Fairfield Cemetery in Fairfield, Solano County, California
  • Married: Jan 28, 1928, Forest Wayne “Frosty” Rosenberry, Casper, Natrona County, Wyoming
  • Two children: Charlotte Dell Rosenberry, Billy Wayne Rosenberry

Della Chatfield & Elmer Ellsworth Chatfield Timeline

History, Census Records, Newspaper Articles, Letters, etc.:
Book Excerpt Census Record Letter, Family Note, Diary
Military Record Newspaper Voter Record, Land Record, City Directory

Note: The spelling and punctuation in the following census records, certificates, newspaper articles, documents and letters have been copied as written (though periods were added in some letters to have them make sense). However, you won’t remember this and will send me notes wanting to correct them.

Jan 4, 1872: Birth of Della “Dell” Chatfield, 1st living child of Clark Samuel Chatfield, Sr. & Mary Elizabeth Morrow in Tecumseh, Johnson County, Nebraska.

Jun 11, 1880: Federal Census for Littleton, Arapahoe County, Colorado:
Chatfield, C.S.: age 39, married, rancher, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born OhioChatfield, Marey: age 29, wife, housekeeping, born Illinois, father born Illinois, mother born Illinois

Chatfield, Ida: age 13, daughter, at school, born Nebraska, father born Ohio, mother born Illinois

Chatfield, Della: age 8, daughter, born Nebraska, father born Ohio, mother born Illinois

Chatfield, Ora: age 7, daughter, born Nebraska, father born Ohio, mother born Illinois

Chatfield, Clark S.: age 8, son, born Nebraska, father born Ohio, mother born Illinois

Chatfield, Arthur: age 1, son, born Nebraska, father born Ohio, mother born Illinois

Howell, L.C.: age 32, farmer, born West Virginia

Baker G.R.: age 23, farmer, born West Virginia

Baker, R.M.: age 31, dentist, born West Virginia

Note: Clark Sr. was born in 1838 so is age 42, not 39; Clark S. Jr. is 3, not 8.

Jun 1, 1885: State Census for Eagle County, Colorado (preprinted date of Jun 1, 1885):
Chatfield, C.P.: age 44, married, rancher, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio (note: C.S.) Chatfield, M.E.: age 35, wife, housekeeper, born Illinois, father born Illinois, mother born Illinois

Chatfield, Ida: age 18, daughter, at school, born Nebraska, father born Ohio, mother born Illinois

Chatfield, Della: age 13, daughter, at school, born Nebraska, father born Ohio, mother born Illinois

Chatfield, Ora: age 12, daughter, at school, born Nebraska, father born Ohio, mother born Illinois

Chatfield, Clark S.: age 9, son, born Nebraska, father born Ohio, mother born Illinois

Chatfield, Arthur: age 8, son, born Nebraska, father born Ohio, mother born Illinois

Chatfield, Willard: age 4, son, born Colorado, father born Ohio, mother born Illinois

Chatfield, Mable: age 1, daughter, born Colorado, father born Ohio, mother born Illinois

Note: Census year begins Jun 1, 1884 and ends May 31, 1885, so not known actual date census was taken.

The Clark Samuel Chatfield family appears in the 1885 Eagle County Census and the 1885 Pitkin County Census, having a home in Aspen and in Emma, Colorado. The town of Emma (Pitkin County) is adjacent to Basalt (Eagle County), with the county line running between the two towns. The town of Emma is no longer in existence.

Jun 1, 1885: State Census for Pitkin County, Colorado (preprinted Jun 1, 1885:
Chatfield, C.: age 45, married, ranchman, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio (note: Clark Samuel)Chatfield, Mary: age 35, wife, keeps house, born Illinois, father born Illinois, mother born Illinois

Chatfield, Ida: age 19, daughter, at school, born Illinois, father born Ohio, mother born Illinois

Chatfield, Dell: age 13, daughter, at school, born Nebraska, father born Ohio, mother born Illinois

Chatfield, Geo: age 11, son, at school, born Nebraska, father born Ohio, mother born Illinois (note: Ora, daughter)

Chatfield, Clark S.: age 9, son, at school, born Nebraska, father born Ohio, mother born Illinois

Chatfield, A.: age 7, son, at school, born Nebraska, father born Ohio, mother born Illinois (note: Arthur)

Chatfield, Willard: age 4, son, born Colorado, father born Ohio, mother born Illinois

Chatfield, Mabel: age 1, daughter, born Colorado, father born Ohio, mother born Illinois

Note: The name entry after Dell cannot be read on the actual record: Ora was transcribed as Geo—and then mistakenly assumed a boy.

Jul 12, 1884: Aspen Weekly Times, Aspen, Pitkin County, Colorado (pg 4):
Misses. Della and Ora Chatfield spent the Fourth and several days of this week visiting friends in Aspen.
Note: Della (age 12) and Ora (turned 11 on Jul 19) are sisters

Jun 28, 1890: Aspen Weekly Times, Aspen, Pitkin County, Colorado (pg 4):
The Eames Reception.

Mr. and Mrs. Eames have determined to leave Aspen, Mr. Eames having made business connections in the southern part of the state. They will take their departure to-morrow, and the reception given them at the Hotel Jerome last evening was in the nature of a farewell to their friends here.

The guests began to arrive by 9 0’clock and by 10 the large parlors were crowded.

The dining room was cleared and soon after 10 o’clock the Silver Crescent Orchestra struck up a march which was a signal for the company to repair to the dancing floor…

Among the guests of the evening were the following: … J.A. Small,
Della Chatfield, Lizzie Gerard, Jacqueline Chatfield, …(et al)

Note: Della (age 14) and Jacqueline (age 22) are cousins. J.A. Small is the future husband of Ella Chatfield.

Jan 2, 1892: Rocky Mountain Sun, Aspen, Pitkin County, Colorado (pg 3):
SOCIAL AND PERSONAL.

Miss Della Chatfield is in the city a guest of relatives.

Sep 15, 1892: Ogden Standard-Examiner, Ogden, Weber County, Utah:
County Clerk Ledwidge yesterday issued marriage licenses to Elmer F. Chatfield, aged 29 and Miss Della Chatfield, aged 20, both of Emma

Sep 18, 1892: Marriage of Della Chatfield and Elmer Ellsworth Chatfield, first cousins, in Ogden, Weber County, Utah. Della (age 20) is the daughter of Clark Samuel Chatfield, Sr. & Mary Elizabeth Morrow and Elmer (age 29) is the son of Isaac Willard Chatfield & Eliza Ann Harrington. At the time of their marriage, both were residents of Emma, Pitkin County, Colorado. As the family possibly frowned upon their marriage due to familial relationship, they may have travelled to Utah to wed. Their marriage record is in Weber County, Utah (ID#313658) and appears to have been taken out on Sep 14, 1892.

1893: According to family lore, Della is a contralto with the Chicago Opera Company and sings at the World’s Columbian Exposition in Chicago, Illinois, the celebration of the 400th anniversary of Christopher Columbus’ discovery of the New World.

World’s Columbian Exposition (aka Chicago World’s Fair)
The World’s Columbian Exposition, held in Chicago in 1893, was the last and the greatest of the nineteenth century’s World’s Fairs. Nominally a celebration of Columbus’ voyages 400 years prior, the Exposition was in actuality a reflection and celebration of American culture and society—for fun, edification, and profit—and a blueprint for life in modern and postmodern America.Millions of American and foreign visitors packed the fairgrounds from May to October, braving rain and mud, blistering heat, and the occasional pickpocket. They covered the 633 acres of Jackson Park in two to four days, some staying for a week or even more.

It was widely publicized both nationally and internationally, and people traveled from all over the world to see the spectacle. Travelers came from the East by “Exposition Flyers”—Pullman coaches traveling at the amazing speed of 80 mph—which gave “many Americans their first look at the country beyond the Alleghenies…”. People left their factories, their farms, and their city businesses to participate in what was touted as the greatest cultural and entertainment event in the history of the world.

The goals of the management and the reactions of the public to this massive event reveal a great deal about the state of America at the close of the Gilded Age. The early 1890s were a time of considerable turmoil in America, and the conflicting interests and ideas found full play in the presentation and reception of the Fair. It was an age of increasing fragmentation and confusion, of self-conscious searching for an identity on a personal and on a national level. The industrial, and increasingly electrical, revolutions were transforming America; the American way of life was no longer based on agriculture, but on factories and urban centers, and the end of the Gilded Age signified the advent of what Alan Trachtenberg has called the “incorporation of America,” the shift of social control from the people and government to big business. The accompanying shift from a producer to a consumer society and the incredible growth of these corporations led to financial instability. Recessions and the devastating Depression of 1893, the violent Homestead and Pullman labor strikes, and widespread unemployment and homelessness plagued the early years of the decade. The frontier was closing, immigration, technological advances, and the railroads had changed the face of the country, and suddenly “Americanness” was more and more difficult to define. Americans were at once confused, excited, and overwhelmed.

While visitors flocked to the Fair’s physical representation of unity, and in some sense utopia, reality had a terrible way of sneaking in. There were constant reminders of the growing economic problems of the country, which deepened into a four-year depression in the summer of 1893. Many conservatives believed the depression was caused by the Sherman Silver Purchase Act, which they claimed undermined business confidence in the Gold Standard. Others found the genesis of the downturn in the weakness of the banking system, the growing economic interdependence in the country, but most of all the rapid expansion of the railroad industry, which had grown beyond demand due to competition. (Faulkner, 143) As railroads began to fail, the fortunes of industries allied with the railroads began to take a downturn as well—especially a number of prominent banks. Over the course of the four-year depression, 15,000 businesses failed, 600 banks closed, 50 railroads became insolvent, and at least 2.5 million Americans were unemployed.

Note: The fair opened to the public on May 1, 1893 and continued through Oct 30, 1893. About 27 million people—about half the U.S. population—attended.Online source: http://xroads.virginia.edu/~MA96/WCE/title.html; published Aug 1, 1996

Feb 15, 1894: Birth of Helen Layle Chatfield, 1st child of Della & Elmer Chatfield, in Emma, Pitkin County, Colorado.

Feb 25, 1896: Birth of Marion Hortense Chatfield, 2nd child of Della & Elmer Chatfield, in Spring Creek near Ten Sleep, Big County, Wyoming.

Oct 18, 1898: Birth of Sevilla “Shirley” Maude Chatfield, 3rd child of Della & Elmer Chatfield, in Spring Creek near Ten Sleep, Big Horn County, Wyoming.

Jun 15, 1900: Federal Census for Spring Creek, Big Horn County, Wyoming:
Chatfield, Elmer: Head, born Jun 1863, age 36, married 7 years, born Colorado, father born Illinois, mother born Illinois, farmer, 82 farm animals
Note: 3 others listed in household, 2 farm laborers and a housekeeperNote: Della (5 months pregnant with their 4th child, Audrey) and their daughters, Helen, Marion, & Sevilla are not listed as they are visiting Dell’s mother and father in Basalt, Eagle County, Colorado

Nov 27, 1900: Birth of Audrey Ella Chatfield, 4th child of Della and Elmer Chatfield, in Spring Creek near Ten Sleep, Big County, Wyoming.

Dec 18, 1905: Birth of Constance “Babe” “Connie” Cordelia Chatfield, 5th child of Della & Elmer Chatfield, in Basin, Big Horn County, Wyoming.

Mar 6, 1906: Death of Clark Samuel Chatfield, Sr. (age 67), father of Della. Clark, in Princeton, Colusa County, California while staying with Dell’s sister, Jacquelin (Chatfield) Mallon.

Della & Elmer’s five girls at the ranch at Spring Creek, Wyoming, about 1910

Audrey, Marion, Helen, Sevilla, and Constance “Babe” hanging on to her hat

May 9, 1910: Federal Census for Spring Creek, Big Horn County, Wyoming:
Chatfield, Elmer E.: Head, age 47, married 1 for 17 years, born Colorado, father born Illinois,mother born Illinois, stock grower on rangeChatfield, Della: wife, age 36, married 1 for 17 years, 5 children born, 5 children living, born Nebraska, father born Illinois, mother born Missouri

Chatfield, Helen L.: daughter, age 16, born Colorado, father born Colorado, mother born Nebraska

Chatfield, Marion H.: daughter, age 14, born Wyoming, father born Colorado, mother born Nebraska

Chatfield, Sevilla M.: daughter, age 11, born Wyoming, father born Colorado, mother born Nebraska

Chatfield, Audrey E.: daughter, age 9, born Wyoming, father born Colorado, mother born Nebraska

Chatfield, Constance C.: daughter, age 4, born Wyoming, father born Colorado, mother born Nebraska

1914: Elmer and Della sell the Spring Creek ranch to the Taylor brothers and move to Worland, Washakie County, Wyoming.

Late Sep 1919: Della is in ill health and Elmer takes her for diagnosis to the Mayo Clinic in Rochester, Minnesota. The doctors tell them she has cancer—and that there is nothing they can do for her.

Oct 2, 1919: The Worland Grit, Worland, Washakie County, Wyoming (pg 10):

YOU AND YOUR NEIGHBOR

Mrs. Elmer Chatfield returned home this week from Rochester, Minnesota, where she had gone for medical treatment at the Mayo hospital.

Oct 31, 1919: Death of Della Chatfield (age 47), wife of Elmer Chatfield and 1st child of Clark S. Chatfield, Sr. & Mary Elizabeth Morrow, on Halloween night, from cancer, in Worland, Washakie County, Wyoming. Her four older daughters are in their twenties, the youngest, Babe, is fourteen. Some family recollect Dell died from breast cancer—others, uterine or ovarian cancer.

Nov 1, 1919: Western Union Telegram from Elmer Chatfield to brother-in-law, Fred Adams:

Nov 4, 1919: Della is buried in the Riverview Cemetery in Worland, Washakie County, Wyoming.

Note: Della headstone is engraved in error. She was born in 1872 and died in 1919.

Nov 6, 1919: Worland Grit, Worland, Washakie County, Wyoming:
Della B. Chatfield, wife of Elmer E Chatfield, a well known stockman and farmer of this section, died at their home north of the City last Friday evening. She had just recently returned from the hospital at Rochester, Minn. and the community held hope the end was not so near. Besides her husband she leaves five daughters, Helen, Marion, Sevilla, Audrey and Babe all residing at home. Funeral services were held at the home last Monday afternoon, the services being in charge of the Rev. William Gorst.
Note: This is the only record found showing Della having a middle initial (though tis not a reliable source)