6. Isaac Chatfield & Lucy Tomlinson

by Catherine Sevenau on May 11, 2011

FAMILY LINE AND HISTORY

Isaac Chatfield

  • 1st child of Joel Chatfield & Ruth Stoddard
  • Born: Jan 15, 1787, Derby, New Haven, Connecticut
  • Died: Aug 1, 1861 (age 74), North Ridgeville, Lorain County, Ohio
  • Buried: Ridgeville Cemetery in North Ridgeville, Lorain County, Ohio
  • Occupation: Teacher, town officer and politician in Middlefield, Ohio
  • Religion: Episcopalian
  • Affiliation: Mason
  • Married: 1806, Lucy Tomlinson, Derby, New Haven, Connecticut
  • Eleven children: Lucius Napoleon Chatfield, Lucy Almira Chatfield, Albert Alonzo Chatfield, LEVI TOMLINSON CHATFIELD, Nathan Stoddard Chatfield, Ruth Ann Chatfield, Charles Henry Chatfield(#1), Charlotte Ann Chatfield, Marie/Maryetta Antoinette Chatfield, Gilbert Lafayette Chatfield, Georgianna A. Chatfield

Lucy Tomlinson

    • Daughter of Levi Tomlinson, Sr. & Amelia Beard
    • Born: Mar 20, 1787, Woodbridge, New Haven, Connecticut
    • Died: Aug 20, 1872 (age 85), North Ridgeville, Lorain County, Ohio
    • Buried: Ridgeville Cemetery in North Ridgeville, Lorain County, Ohio
    • Married (1): 1806, Isaac Chatfield, Derby, New Haven, Connecticut
    • Eleven children: Lucius Napoleon Chatfield, Lucy Almira Chatfield, Albert Alonzo Chatfield, LEVI TOMLINSON CHATFIELD, Nathan Stoddard Chatfield, Ruth Ann Chatfield, Charles Henry Chatfield(#1), Charlotte Ann Chatfield, Marie/Maryetta Antoinette Chatfield, Gilbert Lafayette Chatfield, Georgianna A. Chatfield
    • Married (2): Oct 1, 1868 or Mar 1870, James W. Herrick, North Ridgeville, Lorain County, Ohio
      Note: Lucy (age 81), James (age 80)

James Herrick: son of Isaac Herrick & Prudence Avery
Born: May 24, 1788, Worthington, Hampshire County, Massachusetts
Died: Jan 10, 1873 (age 84), Cleveland, Cuyahoga County, Ohio
Buried: Locust Grove Cemetery in Twinsburg, Summit County, Ohio w/2nd wife, Deborah Tomlinson
Military: Served in War of 1812
Married (1): Aug 10, 1810, Rosetta Riley, Twinsburg, Summit County, Ohio
Two children: Louisa Herrick, Polly M. Herrick
Married (2): Sep 3/4, 1817, Deborah Tomlinson, Geauga County, Ohio,
Seven children: James T. Herrick, Eliza Marthen Herrick, Mary Herrick,
Elizabeth “Betsy” P. Herrick, Sarah D. Herrick, Ezra S. Herrick, Almyra Herrick
Married (3): Oct 1, 1868 or Mar 1870, Lucy (Tomlinson) Chatfield, North Ridgeville, Lorrain County, Ohio

1. Lucius/Lucious/Lucas Napoleon/Nepoleon Chatfield

    • Born: Apr 18, 1807, Seymour (at Skokorat), New Haven, Connecticut
    • Died: Dec 7, 1884 (age 77), Ottokee, Fulton County, Ohio
    • Buried: Ottokee Cemetery in Ottokee, Fulton County, Ohio
    • Occupation: Painter, farmer
    • Married: Jul 3, 1828, Malinda Rose, Burton, Geauga County, Ohio
    • Six children: Joel Lester Chatfield, James Lauren Chatfield, Welthy L. Chatfield, Jane H. Chatfield, Albert Chatfield, Alfred Chatfield

Malinda Rose: daughter of Simon/Simeon Hill Rose & Limery Umberfield/Humphreyville
Born: Feb 23, 1807, Burton, Geauga County, Ohio
Died: aft 1880 (living in Dover, Fulton County, Ohio
Buried: unkn prob Ottokee Cemetery in Ottokee, Fulton County, Ohio
Six children: Joel Lester Chatfield, James Lauren Chatfield, Welthy L. Chatfield, Jane H. Chatfield, Albert Chatfield, Alfred Chatfield

2. Lucy Almira Chatfield

    • Born: Jan 4, 1809, Seymour (at Skokorat), New Haven, Connecticut
    • Died: Dec 31, 1850 (age 41), Middlefield (near Burton), Geauga County, Ohio
    • Buried: Middlefield Cemetery in Middlefield, Geauga County, Ohio
    • Married: Oct 2, 1831, Josiah/Joseph Smith Cook, Burton, Geauga County, Ohio
    • Note: Marriage License issued Aug 22, 1831, Batavia, Geauga County, Ohio
    • Five children: Thomas Corwin Cook, Josiah “John” Marcellus Cook, Harriet L. Cook, Lovilla “Lola” A. Cook, Corwin Meriman/William Corwin Cook

Josiah Cook: son of John Cook & Meroa Smith
Born: May 10, 1810, Burton, Geauga County, Ohio
Died: Feb 20, 1876 (age 66/68) Burton, Geauga County, Ohio
Buried: Welton Cemetery in Burton, Geauga County, Ohio
Married (1): Oct 2, 1831, Lucy Almira Chatfield, Burton, Geauga County, Ohio
Five children: Thomas Corwin Cook, Josiah “John” Marcellus Cook, Harriet L. Cook, Lovilla “Lola” A. Cook, Corwin Meriman/William Corwin Cook
Married (2): Mar 17, 1852, Harriet Electa Whitney, Claridon, Geauga County, Ohio

Harriett Whitney: daughter of John Whitney & Olive Mason
Born: Jul 26, 1829, Ellisburgh, Jefferson County, New York
Died: aft 1874
Buried: Welton Cemetery in Burton, Geauga County, Ohio

3. Albert Alonzo Chatfield

    • Born: Sep 2, 1811, Seymour (at Skokorat), New Haven, Connecticut
    • Died: bef 1843, Ohio or Michigan (note: questionable death date & location)
    • Note: Records have death Dec 1, 1851 (age 40), Mich., but Elizabeth was a widow at 2nd marriage
    • Buried: unkn
    • Married: Oct 13, 1832, Elizabeth/Eliza Kirtland/Kortland, Chardon, Geauga County, Ohio
    • Two children: Sterling Sherman Chatfield, Henry E. “Hank” Chatfield

Elizabeth Kirtland (Curtland): daughter of Frederick Kirtland & Sophia Parkman
Born: Jun 30, 1811, Geauga County, Ohio
Died: Dec 12, 1891 (age 80), Remus, Mecosta County, Michigan
Buried: Nov 1892, remains brought to Hudson, Lenawee County, Michigan for interment
Married (1): Oct 13, 1832, Albert Alonzo Chatfield, Chardon, Geauga County, Ohio
Married (2): Jan 2, 1843, Horace Rice

Horace Rice: son of Joseph Rice & Mary Green or Mary Burnell
Born: May 19, 1806, Madison County, New York
Died: 1852 (abt age 46), on his way overland to California
Buried: unkn
Occupation: Blacksmith
Married (1): Jan 8, 1834, Julia Ann Wheat, New York
Four children: Mary Elizabeth Rice, Eliza Ann Rice, Charlotte Rice, Sidney Wheat Rice
Married (2): Jan 2, 1843, Elizabeth (Kirtland) Chatfield (a widow)
Two children: Horace T. Rice, Arthur Rice

4. LEVI TOMLINSON CHATFIELD

  • Born: Aug 28, 1813, Seymour (at Skokorat), New Haven, Connecticut
  • Died: Nov 11, 1848 (age 35), Middlefield, Geauga County, Ohio
  • Buried: Middlefield (Village) Cemetery in Middlefield, Geauga County, Ohio
  • Married: Jul 22, 1835, LOVINA/LAVINA MASTICK, Chardon, Geauga County, Ohio
  • Four children: ISAAC WILLARD CHATFIELD, Clark Samuel Chatfield, Charles Henry Chatfield, Ellen Charlotte Chatfield

5. Nathan Stoddard Chatfield

    • Born: Oct 3, 1815, Seymour (at Skokorat), New Haven, Connecticut
    • Died: Aug 22, 1885 (age 69), Littleton, Arapahoe County, Colorado
    • Buried: Littleton Cemetery in Littleton, Arapahoe County, Colorado
    • Married: Aug 19, 1841, Margaret Prudentia Herrick, Geauga County, Ohio
    • Seven children: Edward Livingston Chatfield, David Avery Chatfield, William Stoddard Chatfield, Isaac Newton Chatfield, James Herrick Chatfield, Charles Henry Chatfield, Mary Margaret Chatfield

Margaret Herrick: daughter of David Herrick & Zipporah Avery
Born: May 19, 1818, Worthington, Hampshire County, Massachusetts
Died: Oct 10, 1887 (age 69), Littleton, Arapahoe County, Colorado
Buried: Littleton Cemetery in Littleton, Arapahoe County, Colorado
Married: Aug 19, 1841, Nathan Stoddard Chatfield, Geauga County, Ohio
Seven children: Edward Livingston Chatfield, David Avery Chatfield, William Stoddard Chatfield, Isaac Newton Chatfield, James Herrick Chatfield, Charles Henry Chatfield, Mary Margaret Chatfield

6. Ruth Ann Chatfield

    • Born: Aug 10, 1817, Seymour (at Skokorat), New Haven, Connecticut
    • Died: Apr 15, 1904 (age 86), Middlefield, Geauga County, Ohio
    • Buried: Middlefield Cemetery in Middlefield, Geauga County, Ohio
    • Married: May 7, 1834, Samuel Fowler Bishop, Geauga County, Ohio
    • Eight children: twins died as infants, Frances Charlotte Bishop, Josephine V. Bishop, Rosalie Bishop, Rosette “Zetta” B. Bishop, Ruth Ann Bishop, Samuel Lester Bishop

Samuel Bishop: son of Jesse Barnes Bishop & Molly Fowler
Born: Jun 5, 1810, Middlefield, Geauga County, Ohio
Died: Oct 26, 1849 (age 39), Chicago, Cook County, Illinois
Buried: Middlefield Cemetery in Middlefield, Geauga County, Ohio
Married (1): bef 1833, Emmeline A. Stuart (Jun 13, 1819 – )
Married (2): May 7, 1834, Ruth Ann Chatfield, Geauga County, Ohio
Eight children: twins died as infants, Frances Charlotte Bishop, Josephine V. Bishop, Rosalie Bishop, Rosette “Zetta” B. Bishop, Ruth Ann Bishop, Samuel Lester Bishop

7. Charles Henry Chatfield(#1)

    • Born: Sep 15, 1819, Batavia (now Middlefield), Geauga County, Ohio
    • Died: aft 1900, White Hall, Muskegon County, Michigan (1900 census: Eden, Mason Co., Michigan)
    • Buried: unkn
    • Occupation: Farmer, carriage maker
    • Married (1): abt 1843, Marietta/Margrett/Martha Gay
    • Six children: Lucinda “Lucy” Chatfield, Isaac N. Chatfield, Charlotte Chatfield, Charles “Henry” Chatfield II, James Chatfield, John Wesley Chatfield

Marietta Gay: daughter of Nathan Gay & Nancy ___
Born: abt 1826, New York
Died: bet 1860 & 1865) prob Whitehall, Muskegon County, Michigan
Buried: unkn
Six children: Lucinda “Lucy” Chatfield, Isaac N. Chatfield, Charlotte Chatfield, Charles “Henry” Chatfield II, James Chatfield, John Wesley Chatfield

    • Married (2): abt 1870, Susan M. ___
    • Three children: Marsella Chatfield, Almira “Mira” Chatfield, Willy/Wiley L. Chatfield

Susan M ____,
Born: abt 1844, Pennsylvania
Died: bef 1900, poss Muskegon County, Michigan
Buried: unkn
Three children: Marsella Chatfield, Almira “Mira” Chatfield, Willy/Wiley L. Chatfield

8. Charlotte Ann Chatfield

  • Born: Apr 3, 1822, Batavia (now Middlefield), Geauga County, Ohio
  • Died: Oct 8, 1844 (age 22), Middlefield, Geauga County, Ohio
  • Buried: Middlefield (Village) Cemetery in Middlefield, Geauga County, Ohio
  • Never married

9. Mary/Maria/Mary Etta/Margrett Antoinette Chatfield

    • Born: Apr 6, 1824, North Ridgeville, Lorain County, Ohio
    • Died: Jul 11, 1909, North Ridgeville, Lorain County, Ohio
    • Buried: Ridgeville Cemetery in North Ridgeville, Lorain County, Ohio
    • Married (1): Jan 21, 1841, Jackson Robb, Geauga County, Ohio (license date)
    • Five children: Georgianna “Georgia” A. Robb, Charlotte “Lottie” Robb, Mary “Minnie” Elizabeth Robb, Frank Gordon Robb, Susan A. Robb

Jackson Robb: son of John Robb & Susannah Gordon
Born: Jan 6, 1817, Robbstown (West Newton) Westmoreland County, Pennsylvania
Died: Feb 4, 1865 (age 48), North Ridgeville, Lorain County, Ohio
Buried: Ridgeville Cemetery in North Ridgeville, Lorain County, Ohio
Occupation: Farmer
Married (1): Jan 21, 1841,Mary Etta Chatfield, Geauga County, Ohio
Five children: Georgianna “Georgia” A. Robb, Charlotte “Lottie” Robb,
Mary “Minnie” Elizabeth Robb, Frank Gordon Robb, Susan A. Robb
Married (2): aft 1870, __  Rogers, prob Ohio

10. Gilbert Lafayette Chatfield

    • Born: Apr 4, 1826, North Ridgeville, Lorain County, Ohio
    • Died: Mar 3, 1909 (age 82), Ferris, Montcalm County, Michigan
    • Buried: Ferris Center Cemetery in Vestaburg, Montcalm County, Michigan
    • Occupation: Farmer
    • Married: abt 1850, Eliza A. Sellers, Ohio or Michigan
    • Five children: Charlotte Chatfield, Charles A. Chatfield, Frederick Chatfield, Julia E. Chatfield, Gilbert L. Chatfield, Ada W. Chatfield, Dora Chatfield

Eliza Sellers: daughter of George Sellers & Nancy Damoth
Born: Jun 4, 1827, Greene County, Pennsylvania
Died: Jul 11, 1896 (age 69), Ferris Township, Montcalm County, Michigan
Buried: Ferris Center Cemetery in Vestaburg, Montcalm County, Michigan
Five children: Charlotte Chatfield, Charles A. Chatfield, Frederick Chatfield, Julia E. Chatfield, Gilbert L. Chatfield, Ada W. Chatfield, Dora Chatfield

11. Georgianna/Georgiana A. Chatfield

    • Born: Jan 14, 1829, North Ridgeville, Lorain County, Ohio
    • Died: Aug 7, 1855 (age 26), Middlefield, Geauga County, Ohio
    • Buried: Middlefield (Village) Cemetery in Middlefield, Geauga County, Ohio
    • Married: Apr 7, 1852, John Cummings, Geauga County, Ohio
    • No children

(John Cummings:
Born: abt 1825, Ireland)


Isaac Chatfield & Lucy Tomlinson Timeline

History, Census Records, Newspaper Articles, Letters, etc.:
Book Excerpt Census Record Letter, Family Note, Diary
Military Record Newspaper Voter Record, Land Record, City Directory

Note: The spelling and punctuation in the following census records, certificates, newspaper articles, documents and letters have been copied as written (though periods were added in some letters to have them make sense). However, you won’t remember this and will send me notes wanting to correct them.

BATAVIA
When our township was first organized it was named Batavia, and was so called until 1841. The records for the spring of that year have the name Batavia, and in July, of the same year, it was called Middlefield, its present name.
Source: History of Geauga County, Ohio, by Historical Society of Geauga County, pub 1880 (pg 737)
Village Cemetery, Middlefield, Geauga County, Ohio
16094 E. High St./Rt. 87, Active Cemetery:
  • Located on the north side of Rt. 87, about ½ mile east of the intersection of Rts. 87 & 608
  • The cemetery is divided into blocks east and west of the center driveway
  • Each side is divided into rows, by number, and lots, by letter
  • Most lots on the west side have eight graves. Lots on the east side have either eight or ten graves
  • Rows go from 10 through 52 on the west and 10 through 51 on the east
  • Rows 40 (East) and 41 (West) begin the new section; most burials take place in those rows

CHATFIELD

Burial records in Middlefield, Village Cemetery, Middlefield, Geauga County, Ohio:

  • CHATFIELD, Charlotte, Middlefield Village Cemetery
  • CHATFIELD, Georgiana, Middlefield Village Cemetey
  • CHATFIELD, Levi T., Middlefield Village Cemetery

Headstones read:

  • Charlotte: Daughter of Isaac & Lucy Chatfield, died Oct 8, 1844, age 22 yr
  • Georgiana: Daughter of Isaac & Lucy Chatfield, died Aug 7, 1855, age 26 1/2 yr
  • Levi T.: son of Isaac & Lucy Chatfield, died Nov 11, 1848, age 35 yr
THE CHATFIELD STORY
Lucy Tomlinson Chatfield — The grandmother and matriarch.Lucy was a wise and sturdy frontier woman. Everyone called her “Grandma Lucy.” She was born in 1787 and was raised in the strict New England culture of Woodbridge, Connecticut. At the age of 19, she married Isaac Chatfield of Derby Connecticut and settled in Seymour, both localities within six miles of her birthplace. She gave birth to her first five children in Seymour: Lucius Napoleon (1807), Lucy Almira (1809), Albert Alonzo (1811), Levi Tomlinson (1813), and Nathan Stoddard—her fifth—in 1815. The following year (1816) Lucy, Isaac, and the five children moved west to the rugged, remote, undeveloped land of Middlefield, Geauga County, Ohio—then called Batavia—one of the Connecticut Land Company’s fledgling townships. In Middlefield, Lucy would bear six more children, Georgiana, her last-born in 1829. Sadly, she would lose five of her 11 children before the war started, a bitter lesson she could not ignore. After removing to North Ridgeville and then losing her husband, her letters from 1862 forward read like sermons—firm, God-fearing instruction from an experienced pioneer woman. She was dearly loved. Even Margaret, her son’s wife, called her “Mother.” Lucy was 75 years old when Edward enlisted.Isaac Chatfield — The grandfather. Like his wife, he was born in 1787. College educated, he was a knowledgeable farmer and politically popular, elected as Geauga County’s Land Lister in 1821. A good reader, he often delivered passages to members of the Episcopal Church, the first religious edifice constructed in Middlefield in 1829. After dividing among his children what land he had not sold off to others, he and Lucy moved to North Ridgefield in 1860, where he died shortly before the outbreak of the war.
Source: Thompson, Pioneer and General History of Geauga County, 731; The Chatfield Story: The Civil War Letters and Diaries of Private Edward L. Chatfield of the 113th Illinois Volunteers, Terry M. McCarty with Margaret Ann (Chatfield) McCarty, Book Surge, Charleston, South Carolina, 2008; mccarty@chatfieldstory.com

1806: Marriage of Isaac Chatfield and Lucy Tomlinson in Derby, New Haven, Connecticut. Isaac and Lucy were both were 19 years of age.

1810: Federal Census for Harwinton Township, Litchfield County, Connecticut:
Isaac Chatfield: 1 adult, 1 adult female, 1 male age 10-15, 2 children
Apr 8, 1815: Columbian Register, New Haven, Connecticut (pg 4):
List of Letters,Remaining in the Post-Office New-Haven,

April 1, 1815.

***Persons calling for these letters are requested to mention that they are advertised.

Woodbridge—…, Isaac Chatfield, …,

All letters not called for within 3 months will be sent to the General Post Offices.

WM. H. JONES, P.M.

Sep 26, 1820: The Connecticut Herald, New Haven, Connecticut (pg 3):
☞ To Pensioners.THE following returns have been received from the War Office, viz.

Isaac Chatfield, …

HENRY C. FLAGG, Clerk, C.C.P.

County Court Clerk’s Office, Sept. 25, 1820.

1820: Federal Census for Burton Township, Geauga County, Ohio:
Isaac Chatfield: 1 adult male, 2 adult females, 5 children, and 2 foreigners, not naturalized
1830: Federal Census for Batavia Township, Geauga County, Ohio:
Isaac Chatfield: 1 adult male, 1 adult female, 9 children
1840: Federal Census for Batavia Township, Geauga County, Ohio:
Isaac Chatfield: 1 adult male, 1 adult female, 6 children
Note: in July of 1841, the town of Batavia changed its name to Middlefield
Jul 25, 1850: Federal Census for Dover Township, Fulton County, Ohio:
Lucius Chatfield: age 43, m, carriage maker, Value of Real Estate Owned $800, born ConnecticutMalinda Chatfield: age 43, f, born Ohio

James L. Chatfield: age: 16, m, farmer, born Ohio, attended school within the year

Jane H. Chatfield: age 7, f, born Ohio, attended school within the year

William Sellers: age 18, m, carriage maker, Pennsylvania, attended school within the year

Joel L. Chatfield: age 21, m, farmer, Value of Real Estate $120, born Ohio, married within the year

Catherine Chatfield: age 21, f, born France, married within the yearNote: Lucius Chatfield, 1st child of Isaac Chatfield & Lucy Tomlinson, married to Malinda Rose

Jul 30, 1850: Federal Census for Dover Township, Fulton County, Ohio:
Charles N. Chatfield: age 29, m, carriage maker, Value of Real Estate Owned $400, born OhioMarietta Chatfield: age 24, f, born New York

Gilbert Chatfield: age: 22, m, farmer, Value of Real Estate $150, born Ohio (brother)

Isaac Chatfield: age 4, m, born Ohio

Charlotte Chatfield: age 2, f, born Ohio

Charles Chatfield: age 6/12, m, born OhioNote: Charles Henry Chatfield, 7th child of Isaac Chatfield & Lucy Tomlinson, married to Marietta Gay; Gilbert Chatfield, brother, 10th child of Isaac Chatfield & Lucy Tomlinson

Jul 30, 1850: Federal Census for Benton Township, Geauga County, Ohio:
J.S. Cook: age 40, m, farmer, Value of Real Estate $5,000, born OhioLucy Cook: age 41, f, born Connecticut

J.M. Cook: age: 14, m, farmer, born Ohio, attended school within the year

Harriet L. Cook: age 12, f, born Ohio, attended school within the year

Wm C. Cook: age 2, m, born Ohio

Lucy A. Taylor: age 18, f, born Ohio

John Waterton: age 21, m, farmer, born EnglandNote: Lucy Almira Chatfield, 7th child of Isaac Chatfield & Lucy Tomlinson, married to Josiah S. Cook

Aug 3, 1850: Federal Census for Medina Township, Lenawee County, Michigan:
Horace Rice: age 44, male, blacksmith, Value of Real Estate $1,600, born New YorkElizabeth Rice: age 38, female, born Ohio

Sterling Chatfield: age 16, male, laborer, born Ohio

Henry Chatfield: age 14, male, laborer, born Ohio, attended school within the year

(Note: children of Horace Rice & 1st wife):

Eliza Rice: age 13, female, born Michigan, attended school within the year

Charlotte Rice: age 11, female, born Michigan, attended school within the year

Sidney Rice: age 8, male, born Michigan, attended school within the year

Horace T. Rice: age 4, male, born Michigan, attended school within the year (child of Horace Rice & Elizabeth Chatfield)Note: Elizabeth is the widow of Albert Alonzo Chatfield, 3rd child of Isaac Chatfield & Lucy Tomlinson

Sep 4, 1850: Federal Census for Perry Township, Lake County, Ohio:
Ruth A. Bishop: age 32, female, Value of Real Estate $2,500, born ConnecticutFrances Bishop: age 12, female, born Ohio, attended school within the year

Josephine Bishop: age 10, female, born Ohio, attended school within the year

Rosalia Bishop: age 8, female, born Ohio, attended school within the year

Ruth A. Bishop: age 5, female, born Ohio

Lester Bishop: age 1, male, born Ohio

Wm Morgan Bishop: age 23, male, Farmer, Value of Real Estate $1,000, born EnglandNote: Ruth Ann (Chatfield) Bishop, a widow, 6th child of Isaac Chatfield & Lucy Tomlinson

Sep 13, 1850: Federal Census for Parkman Township, Geauga County, Ohio:
Jackson Robb: age 32, male, farmer, Value of Real Estate Owned $2,200, born PennsylvaniaMargett Robb: age 26, female, born Ohio

George Robb: age 8, male, born Ohio (note: Georgianna, female)

Charlott Robb: age 2, female, born OhioNote: Marie “Margrett” (Chatfield) Robb, 9th child of Isaac Chatfield & Lucy Tomlinson

Sep 19, 1850: Federal Census for Middlefield Township, Geauga County, Ohio:
N.S. Chatfield: male, age 33, farmer, Value of Real Estate $900, born ConnecticutMargaret Chatfield: female, age 29, wife, born Massachusetts

Edward Chatfield: male, age 7, born Ohio, attended school within the year

David Chatfield: male, age 5, born Ohio, attended school within the year

W Chatfield: male, age 2, born Ohio

Isaac Chatfield: male, age 1, born Ohio

Note: Also living in household:

Esther Henick: female, age 24, born Massachusetts

Filetus Leach: male, age 14, born OhioNote: Nathan Stoddard Chatfield, 5th child of Levi Chatfield & Lucy Tomlinson

RESIDENCE: Seymour, New Haven, Connecticut
Leman Chatfield abt 1789 Connecticut MaleSarah Chatfield abt 1800 Connecticut Fem

Thirza Chatfield abt 1797 Connecticut Fem (sister to Lyman)Roll M432_46; Pg# 356; Img. 171

Sep 19, 1850: Federal Census for Middlefield Township, Geauga County, Ohio:
Isaac Chatfield: age 62, farmer, Value of Real Estate $2,500, born ConnecticutLucy Chatfield: age 62, born Connecticut

Georgiana Chatfield: age 21, born Ohio

Note: also living in household:

Solomon Leach: age 35, farmer

Mary Leach: age 20, born OhioNote: living next door to their son, Nathan Stoddard Chatfield (see census record above.

Oct 31, 1850: Federal Census for Mason County, Illinois:
Levina Chatfield: age 40, born Ohio (note: error, born Vermont)Willis Chatfield: age 15, born Ohio (note: Isaac Willard Chatfield)

Clark Chatfield: age 12, born Ohio

Charles Chatfield: 10, born Illinois (note: born Ohio)

Ellen Chatfield: age 4, born IllinoisNote: Levi Tomlinson Chatfield, father, died Nov 11, 1848, leaving Lovina a widow w/four children

1856: I.W. Chatfield (age 19), son of Levi Tomlinson Chatfield & Lovina Mastick, works in the commission business with the firm of Gatton & Ruggles in Bath, Mason County, Illinois for about four years.
Note: Gatton & Ruggles engage in the grain business and run a flourmill in Bath

Kilbourne, Mason County, Illinois—Historical Note
James M. Ruggles, born in 1818, a descendant of a family noted in early colonial history and in the Revolutionary War, came to Bath, Illinois, from Ohio in 1846 and became a popular and prosperous merchant. He was elected state senator in 1852 and wrote “alone and unaided ” the first platform of the Republican party founded in Illinois during this period. In 1856, his good friend, Abraham Lincoln, after delivering a speech in Bath, was entertained in the Ruggles home. This house is now owned and occupied by Mrs. Hazel Oest and is one of the landmarks of our neighboring town. Mr. Ruggles advanced in rank several times while fighting in the Civil War, and at its, close, was named brigadier general for meritorious service. He then made his home in Havana until his death in 1901.
Kilbourne: Yesterday and Today 1870-1970, pub by The Kilbourne Centennial Ass (pg 68) www.archive.org/stream/kilbourneyeterday
Jun 1, 1860: Federal Census for Chippewa Township, Isabella County, Michigan:
Charles H Chatfield: age 39, male, farmer, Value of Real Estate $800, Value of Personal Estate, $150, born OhioMargrett Chatfield: age 35, female, born New York

Isaac Chatfield: age 14, male, born Ohio, attended school within the year

Charlott Chatfield: age 12, female, born Ohio, attended school within the year

Henry Chatfield: age 11, male, born Ohio, attended school within the year

James Chatfield: age 6, male, born MichiganNote: Charles Henry Chatfield, 7th child of Isaac Chatfield & Lucy Tomlinson, married to Marietta

Jun 5, 1860: Federal Census for Dover Township, Fulton County, Ohio:
Lucius N Chatfield: age 52, m, painter, Value of Real Estate $1,000, born ConnecticutMalinda Chatfield: age 52, f, born Ohio
Note: Lucius Chatfield, 1st child of Isaac Chatfield & Lucy Tomlinson, married to Malinda Rose
Jun 14, 1860: Federal Census for Pilot, Kankakee County, Illinois:
Nathan Chatfield: age 43, farmer, Value of Real Estate $2,000, Value of Personal Estate $1,750,
born ConnecticutMargaret P. Chatfield: age 41, wife, born, Massachusetts

Edward L. Chatfield: age 17, school teacher, born Ohio

David A. Chatfield: age 14, born Ohio

William Chatfield: age 12, born Ohio

Isaac N. Chatfield: age 10, born Ohio

James H. Chatfield: age 8, born Ohio

Charles H. Chatfield: age 4, born Ohio

Mary M. Chatfield: age 1, born OhioNote: Nathan Stoddard Chatfield, 5th child of Levi Chatfield & Lucy Tomlinson

Jun 30, 1860: Federal Census for Twinsburg, Summit County, Ohio:
Herrick, James W.: age 72 farmer, Value of Real Estate $4000, Value of Personal Property $1000, born MassachusettsDeborah: age 78, born Connecticut

Crooks, Rhuby: age 18, domestic, Value of Personal Estate $300, born Ohio, attended school within yearNote: James W. Herrick is future and second husband of Lucy Chatfield, sister of Deborah

Jul 3, 1860: Federal Census for Olmsted, Cuyahoga County, Ohio:
Jackson Robb: age 43, male, farmer, Value of Real Estate $6,000, Value of Personal Estate $10,000, born PennsylvaniaMaria Antoinette Robb: age 36, female, born Ohio

Georgeanna A. Robb: age 18, female, born Ohio

Charlotte Robb: age 12, female, born Ohio

Minnie Robb: age 5, female, born Ohio

Frank Robb: age 3, male, born OhioNote: Marie “Margrett” (Chatfield) Robb, 9th child of Isaac Chatfield & Lucy Tomlinson
Last 5 names are incorrectly indexed under “Antoinette”

Jul 5, 1860: Federal Census for Wellington Township, Lorain County, Ohio:
Ruth A. Bishop: age 40, female, Landlady, born ConnecticutFrances Bishop: age 22, female, Seamstress, born Ohio

Josephine Bishop: age 20, female, born Ohio

Rosetta Bishop: age 16, female, born Ohio, attended school within the year

Ruth A. Bishop: age14, female, born Ohio, attended school within the year

Lester Bishop: age 10, male, born Ohio, attended school within the yearNote: Ruth Ann (Chatfield) Bishop, 6th child of Isaac Chatfield & Lucy Tomlinson; 16 others reside in household known as the “Bishop House”—perhaps a rooming house or small hotel

Aug 2, 1860: Federal Census for Canandaigua Township, Lenawee County, Michigan:
Elisabeth Rice: age 48, female, Value of Real Estate $800, Value of Personal Estate $100, born OhioSterling Chatfield: age 27, male, Lawyer, born Ohio

Henry Chatfield: age 25, male, Carpenter, born Ohio

Note: Children of Horace Rice: (note: 2nd husband of Elizabeth)

H.F. Rice: age 14, male, born Michigan, attended school within the year

Arthur Rice: age 10, male, born Michigan, attended school within the yearNote: Elizabeth is the widow of Albert Alonzo Chatfield, 3rd child of Isaac Chatfield & Lucy Tomlinson

Aug 9, 1860: Federal Census for Middlefield Township, Geauga County, Ohio:
Isaac Chatfield: age 73, farmer, Value of Real Estate $4000, Value of Personal Estate $1000, born Conn.Lucy Chatfield: age 73, born Conn.
Aug 31, 1860: Federal Census for Bath, Mason County, Illinois:
Willard Chatfield: age 23, farm keeper, Value of Personal Estate $100, born Ohio (note: head, Isaac Willard Chatfield)Eliza Chatfield: age 19, born Iowa (note: wife, Eliza Harrington)

Clara E. Chatfield: age 1, born Kansas (note: daughter, Ella Clara)

Ellen C. Chatfield: age 14, born Illinois, attending school (note: Isaac’s sister)

Charles Chatfield: age 19, born Ohio (note: Isaac’s brother)Note: Children of Levi Tomlinson Chatfield (died Nov 11, 1848) and Lovina Mastick (died Apr 2, 1858)

Pioneer and General History of Geauga County, Ohio
Isaac Chatfield moved into town and settled on lot forty, coming from Connecticut, with his wife and children, Lucius, Albert, Almira, Levi, Nathan, Ruthann, Charles, Charlotte, Maryette, LaFayette, and Georgianna. When he settled in town he was considered quite wealthy, for those times, by the people. He paid down, or nearly so for about three hundred acres of land. Mr. Chatfield erected a large two-story house, took an active part in town politics, and having attended college, and being one of the best readers, he read sermons, and, after the organization of the Episcopalian church, he conducted services, in the absence of the minister; also, he taught school several winters. After the children were all married off, the parents resided in that township until 1860 when they sold to Ozro and Orlow Newcomb. They removed to Ridgeville, Ohio, and have since died.What is the present township of Huntsburg, and the township of Middlefield, elected their officers together under the name of Batavia, until, and including, the spring election of 1821. The officers chosen at that election…

Isaac Chatfield, …Lister (recorder; included 9th on the roster of town officers)Source: History of Geauga County, Ohio, by Historical Society of Geauga County, pub 1880 (pg 731 & 732)

Aug 1, 1861: Death of Isaac Chatfield (age 73), father of Levi Tomlinson Chatfield, in North Ridgeville, Lorain County, Ohio. Isaac is buried in the Ridgeville Cemetery in North Ridgeville, Lorain County, Ohio.

Mar 1870: Marriage of Lucy (Tomlinson) Chatfield and James W. Herrick, her second husband, his third wife, in North Ridgeville, Lorraine County, Ohio. Lucy, the widow of Isaac Chatfield, is age 80 and James is 79. James Herrick is the uncle of Margaret Prudentia Herrick who married Nathan Stoddard Chatfield, Lucy Tomlinson & Isaac Chatfield’s 5th born child. James’ second wife, Deborah, was Lucy’s older sister.

Lucy (Tomlinson) Chatfield (m.2) James W. Herrick
1787 – 1873 1788 – 1873

Aug 20, 1870: Federal Census for P.O. Elyria, Ridgeville Township, Lorraine County, Ohio:
Herrick, James: age 73, at home, born Massachusetts, married in March of this yearHerrick, Lucy: age 84, keeping house, born Connecticut, married in March of this year
Note: James Herrick is age 83
Jun 3, 1870: Federal Census for Olmsted, Cuyahoga County, Ohio:
Robb, Mary: age 46, female, Farmer, Value of Real Estate $15,000, Value of Personal Estate $10,000, born OhioRobb, Minnie: age 15, female, born Ohio, attended school within the year

Robb, Frank: age 13, male, born Ohio, attended school within the year

Robb, Susie: age 3, female, born OhioNote: Mary “Margrett” (Chatfield) Robb, now a widow, 9th child of Isaac Chatfield & Lucy Tomlinson; name is indexed incorrectly as Hary Robb

Aug 20, 1872: Death of Lucy (Tomlinson) Chatfield Herrick (age 85), in North Ridgeville, Lorain County, Ohio. Lucy is buried with her 1st husband, Isaac Chatfield, in the Ridgeville Cemetery in North Ridgeville.

Lucy (Tomlinson) Chatfield⇒
Photo courtesy of Terry & Margaret (Chatfield) McCarty

Isaac & Lucy Chatfield’s tall white headstone (in middle of photo) reads:

ISAAC CHATFIELD

Born in Connecticut

Jan 15, 1787.

Was married to

LUCY TOMLINSON 1806.

& came to Ohio 18??.

Died Aug 1, 1861.

Aged 73 yrs & 6 mo

LUCY,

His wife

Born In Connecticut

March 20, 1787.

Died Aug 20, 1872.

____________________

C H A T F I E L D

Jan 1873: Death of James W. Herrick (age 84), 2nd husband of Lucy (Tomlinson) Chatfield, in Cleveland, Cuyahoga County, Ohio. He is buried in the Locust Grove Cemetery in Twinsburg, Ohio with his 2nd wife, Deborah Tomlinson (Lucy’s older sister), who died May 20, 1868.

Jun 15, 1880: Federal Census for Oberlin, Lorain County, Ohio:
Merrill, Jabez W: male, age 84, widowed, Gardening, born New York, father born Connecticut, mother born ConnecticutRogers, Mary A: female, age 55, married, House Keeping, born Ohio, father born Connecticut, mother born Connecticut

Robb, Susie A.: female, age 14, female, at school, born Ohio, father born Pennsylvania, mother born OhioNote: Mary “Margrett” (Chatfield) Robb now Rogers, 9th child of Isaac Chatfield & Lucy Tomlinson.

Jun 6, 1900: Federal Census for Cedartown, Polk County, Georgia:
Russell, Eugene B: Head, male, born Jan 1863, age 37, married, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio, Editor
Russell, Susie: Wife, female, born Jun 1867, age 32, married, born Ohio, father born Ohio, mother born Ohio
Rogers, Mary: Mother-in-law, female, born Apr 1824, age 76, widowed, mother of 1 child, mother of 1 child living, born Ohio, father born Connecticut, mother born Connecticut
Note: Mary “Margrett” (Chatfield) Rogers, nee Robb, 9th child of Isaac Chatfield & Lucy Tomlinson; Mary is indexed with a last name of Russell

Nathan Stoddard Chatfield (5th child of Isaac Chatfield & Lucy Tomlinson):
Nathan Stoddard Chatfield moved to Colorado in 1879 and eventually settled in the Littleton area. He and his wife, Margaret Prudentia Herrick, had seven children, all born in Middlefield, Geauga County, Ohio: Edward Livingston, David Avery, Isaac Newton, William Stoddard, James Herrick, Charles Henry, and Mary Margaret. Five of their offspring accompanied their parents to Colorado. Their son David Avery died during the Civil War, William Stoddard remained in Illinois, and Charles Henry and family came, but removed to Kankakee County, Illinois.

Note: Pictures are courtesy of Terry McCarty &
Margaret (Chatfield) McCarty, great-grandniece
of Edward Livingston Chatfield

Four sons of
Margaret Prudentia Herrick & Nathan Stoddard Chatfield⇒
James Herrick Chatfield
Isaac Newton Chatfield
William Stoddard Chatfield
Edward Livingston Chatfield
circa 1911

Photo courtesy of:
Littleton Historical Society

 

Aug 13, 1892: Littleton Independent, Littleton, Arapahoe County, Colorado (pg 1):
Mr. & Mrs. W.S. Chatfield and children of Kankakee, Illinois are spending a delightful time with their kinsfolks here. Mr. Chatfield is a brother of E.L., I.N. and James Chatfield.
Note: Mr. & Mrs. William Stoddard Chatfield. William is the brother of Edward Livingston Chatfield, Isaac Newton Chatfield and James Herrick Chatfield.